REVIEW: THE MIDNIGHT CALLER by Charles Eades at Old Red Lion Theatre 11 – 15 February 2025

‘masterfully builds an unnerving atmosphere’ ★★★

THE MIDNIGHT CALLER is a chilling thriller that centres on Fiona, who works the night shift at a call centre. Her routine is disrupted by a disturbing phone call from a child in distress. When the police fail to act, she enlists the help of her friend Judy, to uncover the truth - plunging them both into a perilous mystery.

With all the hallmarks of a classic psychological thriller - an isolated protagonist, a setting steeped in a sinister past, and an unsolved murder — the play masterfully builds an unnerving atmosphere. The sound design is pivotal in amplifying suspense, with eerie voices and unsettling noises heightening the tension. Just as effective are the moments of silence, allowing unease to creep in and a lingering sense of powerlessness to take hold.

The performances are strong, with the cast bringing depth and nuance to their roles. Yazmeen Enoch delivers a compelling portrayal of Fiona, capturing both her sense of disconnect from the world and her growing desperation with raw intensity. Opposite her, Treci Dominique shines as Judy. Their interactions add warmth and urgency to the narrative, keeping the story compelling even as it treads familiar ground. Emeka Agada impresses in multiple roles, seamlessly shifting from Fiona’s officious boss to a sympathetic colleague and an apathetic police officer, adding a rich texture to the world around Fiona.

What sets THE MIDNIGHT CALLER apart is its haunting conclusion. Rather than offering a clear resolution to the mystery, the ending remains deliberately ambiguous, leaving audiences questioning what they’ve just witnessed. It’s a bold choice that enhances the play’s unsettling nature.

Though some scenes could benefit from tighter pacing, the production delivers a gripping and suspenseful experience. Fans of supernatural thrillers will appreciate its eerie atmosphere and immersive storytelling, even if it doesn’t break new ground. Strong performances, a meticulously crafted soundscape, and a hauntingly ambiguous conclusion make for an engaging night of theatre.

Starring: Yazmeen Enoch, Emeka Agada (Reacher) and Treci Dominique 

Written By Charles Eades

Directed By Giulia Hallworth

Presented by BlackPen Productions