by Imo Redpath
•
11 November 2024
'A lot of contradictory information to digest, and the audience for this production…quickly lost their appetite’ ½★ Putting on a good play is like cooking a delicious meal. Without a recipe. And therefore only to be attempted by the brave. Multiple – carefully selected – ingredients, prepared lovingly to produce something tasty for a lucky someone to savour and enjoy. Similarly, good theatre is an amalgamation of a tight script, a brave and dedicated cast and crew, shaped and guided by a director and placed in front of an audience to consume and – hopefully – to enjoy. There is no existing recipe for an original piece of theatre and therefore it can only be attempted by the brave writer, bold enough to write a new one. Risks either pay off or they don’t. Unfortunately, P.T. Rose’s play My Wife Fell in Love with A Life Size Cardboard Cut-Out of Ronan Keating takes multiple risks and not a single one of them pays off. The recipe is unclear: the premise of a hodgepodge family (four generations of women, an Elvis impersonator, an Islam convert and a clown) that assemble for Ronan Keating’s birthday (whose cardboard copy stands rigidly upstage, smiling through the whole ordeal) is what drew me to see the show. Alas, I can’t help but regret my decision to eat at this table in the first place. This play, directed by Yvonne Patterson, is about delusion. The delusion of a working-class mother, Sally, whose sexist, fascist, transphobic and racist views of the world have so skewed her reality that she has fallen in love with a cardboard cut-out of Ronan Keating. The delusion of her live-in boyfriend who speaks to her in a tone more revolting than if she was a rat he’d found in his sock drawer. “Carry on cutting your chicken for Keating’s curry and shut your mouth,” he commands, dressed – for some reason – as a clown. And Sally moves from kitchen to sofa, sofa to kitchen, kitchen to Ronan Keating, Ronan Keating to sofa again, in a play so static that one of the audience members was woken up by the final applause. Perhaps the most offensive delusion of all, is that the playwright appears to push a transphobic agenda through Sally and her mother Doreen (whose Ziggy Stardust flash tattoo is big and red and questionable), who shout and shout that no daughter / granddaughter of theirs will be a ‘they’ – as if they have any say in the matter at all. And the writer makes no attempt to sugar coat their belief that education leads to delusion: Phil, Sally’s transgender child has discovered the term non-binary at school and now wants top surgery, but this is construed as an attempt to ‘mutilate’ their body in order to ‘defy societal norms,’ and Sally’s boyfriend, the clown, spends the entire play reading the Financial Times despite recently completing a university module and therefore having found Buddhism, a religion which refutes material wealth. This is a lot of contradictory information to digest, and the audience for this production of My Wife Fell In Love…quickly lost their appetite. There’s a fine line between theatre that comments successfully on societal issues – and takes political shape because it chimes with current events – and theatre that is unapologetically political but cannot decide where it stands on anything. Here we are on that line. P.T. Rose’s play made no sense in the first half, and descended into further senseless chaos in the second, when ex-husband Joe turned Islam convert arrives. He lets himself into the apartment through the age-old cliché of the front door being ‘left wide-open,’ and proceeds to explain that his chosen pronoun is the n-word and insists that everyone call him ‘n***** Joe’ from now on. As I squirmed in my seat, I hoped, I prayed that the writer was trying to say something here, trying to shock us for a reason. But there was absolutely no point to throwing this painful word around, and the jokes that ensued as the outlandish characters corrected themselves and repeated the word over and over were base and gratuitous. Perhaps I join the delusion by attempting to make sense of this play, but one thing I can say for certain is that it was not ready for review. Missed lighting cues, sound issues and a stunt-casted actor who forgot almost all of her lines were just a few indicators that this production was overpriced and under rehearsed. Some actors made the best of a bad situation, others stumbled through the script as poorly as it was written. This is a play where every offensive word or thought is thrown into the space without nuance or soft focus, and yet nothing happens at all. There is bravery involved in disaster. And this play is certainly brave. My Wife Fell in Love with A Life Size Cardboard Cut-Out of Ronan Keating By P.T. Rose, adapted by Tegwyn Burges Directed by Yvonne Patterson Produced by Karen Struel-White & Francoise Pascal Drayton Arms Theatre 5th – 9th November 2024 www.rkplay.net Charlotte Reidie as Sally Meryl Anderson as Doreen Francoise Pascal as Pearl Simon Charles as Clown Nathan Nuurah as Elvis Lily Starkey as Phil Shaz Rocket as Joe Benji Ruhle as The ‘Man’ Reviewer Bio Imo Redpath is a writer and actor for theatre, radio and TV. She graduated with an MFA in Scriptwriting from the Royal Central School of Speech and Drama and her plays ‘Foxes & Rabbits’ and ‘Pigs’ are currently in development. She writes a comedy blog on Substack about living with ADHD in Lon