by Francis Beckett
•
21 March 2025
‘A nice evening in the theatre and a worthwhile, if flawed, tribute to an important thinker, teacher and campaigner.’ ★★★ A theatrical celebration of the turbulent life and pioneering writing of Mary Wollstonecraft is long overdue, and Hull Truck Theatre is to be congratulated for taking it on. Mary’s most famous work, A Vindication of the Rights of Women, trod new ground when it was published in 1792, yet is still read and quoted, still considered fresh and relevant. Hull Truck have opted for a musical version, with much of the action narrated in fast, loud songs with a heavy beat in front of a simple all-purpose brown set. Six talented female actors, singers and dancers, drilled to perfection by movement director Ayesha Fazal, play 22 characters, so all the male parts are portrayed by women – which, in this context, worked perfectly well. The result is a straightforward simple narrative, which zips along satisfyingly and tunefully – there isn’t a dull moment – and leaves you indignant that women, and in particular this woman, should be treated as she was treated. With this method, it’s probably inevitable that the story, and even more Wollstonecraft’s thinking, are massively over-simplified. The songs, though fun to listen to, sometimes feel like slogans, which, however much you approve of the sentiments they express, seldom make good theatre. But there’s a deeper problem. Writer Maureen Lennon, in her programme note, makes the valid point that, feminist icon though Mary is, her life was not one that feminist mothers would hold up to their daughters as a model to be followed. “She is too much, too demanding, needy, argumentative, moralistic, chaotic. She makes absolute judgements and then fails to live up to her own standards.” Yes indeed. What sort of feminist icon tries to kill herself when a male lover rejects her? In this show the lover even outflanks her: “I thought I fell in love with a woman of fire and independence” he tells her. The difficulty comes in balancing the two: the fierce and fluent philosopher and feminist, and the woman who tells us: “Sometimes feminism isn’t enough to keep a girl from wanting love.” And here, I think, the production fails. Laura Elsworthy gives us the chaotic, sometimes pathetic Mary, but not the thinker and scholar. Even when she is teaching, we see too much neurotic despair, and not enough intellectual authority. I suspect – because Elsworthy is clearly a competent actor - that this is the decision of director Esther Richardson. She starts very loud and emotional, which is right because the opening scene is the birth of Mary’s second daughter, during which Mary died at just 38. But after that, there should be some quiet, reflective moments. Instead, she stays on one loud note. There is no variation. She becomes quite hard to listen to – and even to sympathise with. If Mary gets less than justice in the show, she hardly appears in the programme, which is quite an odd document. We learn when both writer and director discovered Mary’s writing (at university in both cases), and how the music composer works, and why the design decisions were made, but in 16 pages there is no space to tell the audience about Mary, about the times, about her significance. Theatre people sometimes get very self-referential. This is a nice evening in the theatre and a worthwhile, if flawed, tribute to an important thinker, teacher and campaigner. And it did make me realise that Mary’s fascinating and difficult life would make an excellent straight play. MARY AND THE HYENAS by Maureen Lennon at Wiltons Music Hall 18-29 March 2025 Box Office https://wiltons.org.uk/whats-on/mary-and-the-hyenas/#wysiwyg_3_in Presented by Pilot Theatre and Hull Truck Theatre CAST Beth Crame – Eliza Wollstonecraft, Dr Price, Margaret Kingsborough Laura Elsworthy – Mary Wollstonecraft Kate Hampson – Mary’s mother Kat Johns-Burke – Fanny Blood, Fuseli, Edward Wollstonecraft Ainy Medina – Mary Shelley, Marguerite, Thomas Paine Elexi Walker – Joseph Johnson, Gilbert Imlay CREATIVES Written by Maureen Lennon Music by Billy Nomates (Tor Maries) Directed by Esther Richardson Designed by Sara Perks