by David Weir
•
6 March 2026
‘high praise, but … ’ ★★★ There are times with reviews when the individual parts of a play merit more than the overall rating and A Murmuration of Starlings is a difficult example of that. The staging’s inventive and ideal for the material. The acting is universally good, with the two male leads in particular, who have, to be fair, the stronger and perhaps showier parts, both demonstrating considerable physical and verbal dexterity, and courage in tackling sensitive themes. The problem, though, and it’s a difficulty it’s impossible to talk about without sounding a little callous, is that life is not drama, and that characters without agency are also characters without conflict or, in the dramatic sense of the term, jeopardy. There’s no solution to a man with dementia. The story told here is moving. The struggles of the characters are deeply felt; as human beings we care for them, but as dramatic characters, they can do nothing to alter their situation, nothing to progress. A highly skilled writer and director swells hearts with sympathy for the human tragedy at the centre of the play, but there’s no dramatic conflict capable of resolution, no hope at the bottom of this Pandora’s box. Two Acts watching characters exist in a situation they cannot resolve rends the senses, but as the gradual realisation dawns that we’ll see a beautifully unfolded fractured flashback telling us how we got to this point in two lives destroyed by dementia, the man and the woman who loves him, so does the realisation grow that there’s nothing at stake until death or, in a play, lights down releases us. That essential difficulty aside, there is so much to admire in Joe Graham’s play. We meet a couple coming home from a walk and immediately realise he (Steve Hay) is a man whose mind is lost while she (Jenny Johns, a perfect picture of stoic frustration) has to cope with his ramblings, repetitions, random digressions and journeys, both physical and verbal, into the past that brought them together. For at its heart, the play’s a love story – an unfolding in broken time and gradually clearing confusion of how their younger selves (Johnny Dagnell and Jennifer Barton) first met, and an exploration of the memories and symbols that hold them together now that one of them, effectively, has gone but still remains. Audiovisuals are used to great effect to create both scenes (a bus stop) and symbolic images (that murmuration of starlings of the title, swirling and swooping wondrously, confusedly, brilliantly, chaotically about the sky). Music’s cleverly integrated, too, both to revive memories and to invite in ‘the monster’ that’s destroying both mind and memory. Is it destroying love? It is certainly testing it to the limit, and the final scenes where the older couple seem close to the end of an horrific tether while the younger couple are tentatively finding each other for the first time is a touching and tender finale. As said at the opening, the parts of this production are individually enough to win high praise, but the overall effect doesn’t quite add up the sum of those parts. A test of endurance for the disintegrating couple with an inevitability that also tests an audience’s endurance even as it reminds them of the discomfort of mortality and the fragility of love. A MURMURATION OF STARLINGS, Written and directed by Joe Graham at Seven Dials Playhouse 3 - 14 March 2026 Box Office: SevenDialsPlayhouse.co.uk Review: David Weir’s plays include Confessional (Oran Mor, Glasgow) and Better Together (Jack Studio, Brockley, London). His novel, The Honourable Member for Murder, will be published in August 2026.